Development Rights are Like Kind to Fee Interest in Real Estate

A newly released private letter ruling, PLR 200901020, reaffirms the IRS's view that development rights are a qualifying interest in real estate which can be like kind to a fee and other interests in real estate for purposes of an exchange under IRC Section 1031. PLR 200805012 previously affirmed the same. Accordingly, development rights can be exchanged for a fee interest in real estate and vice versa.

In order for development rights to be like kind to fee interest in real estate under IRC Section 1031, it is necessary for the state the rights are located in to view such rights as a real estate interest and for the rights to be in perpetuity (as distinguished from rights which are short-term or for a limited period of time). Perpetuity is important. Short-term rights may be an interest in real estate under state law but are not like kind to a fee interest in real estate under IRC Section1031. PLR 200901020 makes this clear.

A qualifying interest in real estate which can be like kind to a fee interest in real estate under IRC Section 1031 can include varying types of real estate interests. PLR 200901020 examines such other types of qualifying interests in real estate including –

• Leasehold interests of 30 years or more
• Easements
• Rights-of-ways
• Water rights
• Mineral rights
• Royalty rights
• Mineral leases

All of these types of real estate interests are considered like-kind to each other under IRC Section 1031 and may be exchanged for each other.

While the privage letter ruling can not be cited as precedent, and the IRS has the right to rule differently on subsequent occasions, it is a useful ruling for the purpose of demonstrating the IRS's view for similar situations. To receive a copy of the PLR, give us a call at 888-367-1031 or send us a message at 1031@1031cpas.com.

Mutual Irrigation Ditch, Reservoir or Irrigation Company Stock

With the recent passage of the Food and Energy Security Act of 2007 (commonly referred to as the Farm Bill), mutual irrigation ditch, reservoir or irrigation stock (“ditch stock”) MAY now be considered like-kind to a fee interest in real estate.

Section 1031 clearly spells out that corporate stock, bonds and notes are not eligible for a like kind exchange. However, the recently passed Farm Bill amends section 1031 to exclude mutual irrigation ditch, reservoir or irrigation company stock from “stocks, bonds, or notes”. With this passage, these water rights may now be eligible for a 1031 exchange - depending on state statute and previous court rulings.

Mutual irrigation ditch, reservoir or irrigation stock is generally considered to be a water right which is used on farm land to irrigate crops. Water, as a mineral, is generally considered to be an interest in real estate. As an interest in real estate, it is generally considered to be like-kind to a fee interest in real estate. Farm land which is sold or exchanged sometimes includes ditch stock that has benefits and value to the sale of that land. Particularly in the western United States, these water rights are critical to the ongoing production ability of the property and are typically sold with the real estate.

In order to qualify, the new law clearly indicates that such ditch stock has to be recognized as real property, or an interest in real property, in the state in which the corporation is located. Recognition can be by the highest court of the state or by applicable state statute. Mutual irrigation ditch companies are organized under separate sections of state statutes and ditch stock has been recognized as an interest in real property by the District Court of Colorado and other court cases. However, ditch stock in other states may or may not qualify.

Exchange clients should be familiar of the state laws and court rulings in the state their exchange property is located. Of course, they should also discuss their circumstances with a knowledgeable real estate attorney or qualified tax professional before embarking on an exchange of water rights. A Qualified Intermediary that is familiar with the special closing and exchange-related issues involving ditch and water stock should also be consulted and engaged to ensure the exchange is completed properly. To learn more about this topic, please consult our 1031 Exchange Manual or give 1031 Corporation Exchange Professionals a call at 888-367-1031.